15 Comments
Oct 28, 2023Liked by Matthew Murray

Thank you for sharing this! Another suspicious thing, Matthew: I get subscribers who have no posts of their own, no likes, no notes. and no profile -- BUT they subscribe to 500-600 substacks! Seems weird to me. I just delete them. Let me know if you have experienced that.

Expand full comment

Thanks Matthew for the info. It's pretty disturbing what our world is coming to.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Matthew! It’s nice to know someone has our backs.

Expand full comment
Oct 27, 2023Liked by Matthew Murray

Thanks for the info, Matt. I noticed that I had a lot of Yahoo email subscribers but didn't think much of it.

Good sleuthing there! :)

Expand full comment

Thanks, Matt for making this info available. Since October 2 I've gained 11 new followers that fit this criteria. I have a small readership and was happy about this uptick in subscriptions, only to now discover it's not legit. :(

Expand full comment

Thanks for the exposure. So irritating these kinds of things exist.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Matthew! No recent subs have the identifiers you list but I'll be on the lookout. Good work. 👍

Expand full comment
Oct 30, 2023Liked by Matthew Murray

We get this sort of subscriber in Tumblr all the time. We’re told to Report them as SPAM then Block them. Works really well. We can see the waves as the people behind them try different approaches to get through. Someone explained what they’re doing and why. I can probably dig up the post if needed but I think it’s based on stuff similar to Facebook where all the interconnected tentacles allow them some sort of access to all our accounts, so I’m VERY relieved that you’re deleting them. I don’t want to leave Substack.

(I’m way behind on my reading. Australia has a lot of gaps in phone coverage and I’ve been in one for the past week. Had a wonderful time, but I have a lot of reading to do now to catch up.)

Thanks for the post Matthew.

Expand full comment

Gosh, that's so interesting - thanks, Matt! I haven't really been paying much attention - when I get a new subscriber who writes their own newsletter I always click through to have a look, but I haven't really looked too closely at actual e-mail addresses.

I've looked now, though, and I do have a few in just the format you've described! 👀 Thank you for drawing my attention to them.

Expand full comment

Good catch, Matt. If you notice that these newsubs have 0 activity with our newsletters. Rather than send them the newsletters, it's probably best just to delete them from your dashboard. Thanks!

Expand full comment